The Renaissance Women Who Painted Against the Odds

HARTFORD — As early as 1971, together with her landmark essay “Why Have There Been No Great Women Artists?” the artwork historian Linda Nochlin made it clear that if you happen to go trying to find forgotten feminine equals to Michelangelo or Poussin, you’re going to be dissatisfied. European girls had been in fact portray, drawing, sketching, weaving, however — way more than their literary counterparts — feminine artists confronted institutional obstacles to their improvement that outweighed any particular person present. No admission to life drawing courses. No apprenticeships in giant studios. No simple hobnobbing with patrons. No entry to prizes or residencies, and even typically paint.

If the sexism of artwork was structural, then the answer must be structural too. Raising a couple of lesser-known (and, to Nochlin’s eye, much less important) girls to the canon of outdated masters was not going to chop it. A feminist artwork historical past would require a critique of the very concept of “greatness,” and a root-and-branch reconstruction of how we assign inventive worth: what the feminist artwork historian Griselda Pollock would later name “differencing the canon.”

Still, there have been extra girls than we’ve identified who beat the chances to turn into skilled artists earlier than the age of revolutions. In 1972, only a 12 months after Nochlin’s salvo, the Walters Art Museum in Baltimore introduced the exhibition “Old Mistresses,” which delivered to the fore Lavinia Fontana, Angelica Kauffman, and different European girls. Larger and extra influential was “Women Artists: 1550—1950,” organized by Nochlin and Ann Sutherland Harris, which related painters from Artemisia Gentileschi to Alice Neel on the Los Angeles County Museum of Art in 1976 and the Brooklyn Museum of Art in 1977. The final 4 years have introduced monographic museum exhibitions — the usual software format for canon membership — of not solely Gentileschi and Kauffman however Fede Galizia, Michaelina Wautier, Elisabetta Sirani and Giovanna Garzoni.

“By Her Hand: Artemisia Gentileschi and Women Artists in Italy, 1500—1800,” on view for a couple of extra weeks right here on the Wadsworth Atheneum, is essentially the most important American present of girls of the Italian Renaissance and Baroque eras since 2007, when the National Museum of Women within the Arts hosted “Italian Women Artists from Renaissance to Baroque.” (The present present has been organized with the Detroit Institute of Arts, to which it’ll journey in February.) Its titular painter could draw essentially the most consideration: Artemisia, star of her very personal film and a number of other based-on-a-true-story performs and novels, could very properly have displaced Caravaggio as Seventeenth-century Italy’s most bankable artwork star.

Yet this present has work, pastels and drawings by sixteen girls, many drawn from non-public collections or else not seen in America for many years. (Two different girls are seen by portraits by males, because the curators had been unable to acquire appropriate loans.) Some of those artists, like Gentileschi and Sirani, had been famend of their day. Others, notably these in non secular orders, labored in whole obscurity. I had by no means heard of a stable third of them.

No denying that Gentileschi dominates the present, ranging from a central wall wherein she stares us down in three tightly cropped self-portraits in three-quarter profile, every performed in Florence in 1615—17. In the just lately rediscovered “Self-Portrait as Saint Catherine of Alexandria,” lent by the National Gallery in London, the artist wears a pink robe and a crown wrapped in a turban. In her proper, drawn to her coronary heart, she holds a palm. Her left hand grazes the spike of the wheel on which she was tortured.

An analogous pose recurs in one other Saint Catherine, lent from the Uffizi. The assured gaze matches the Wadsworth’s personal “Self-Portrait as a Lute Player,” wherein she wears a blue costume with substantial décolletage: an unprecedented self-portrait of a lady depicting herself as sexually fascinating.

Gentileschi used representations of herself, each secular and allegorical, not solely as painterly codecs however vindications of her studying and class. These self-portraits had been strategies of self-promotion, which helped win her commissions for bigger tasks from the kings of England and Spain. (The invocation of Saint Catherine additionally had a public ingredient; on the notorious trial of Gentileschi’s rapist in 1612, she endured torture to “prove” she was telling the reality.) Multi-figure works by Gentileschi right here, such because the grand and grisly “Judith and Her Maidservant With the Head of Holofernes,” show a staggering ambition proper all the way down to the paint dealing with; have a look at the slashing whites in Judith’s shirt sleeves and her servant’s kerchief.

No different artist in “By Her Hand” matches Gentileschi in scale or quantity. This present’s curators, Eve Straussman-Pflanzer and Oliver Tostmann, have thus correctly staged the present in a single open room with a construction of open partitions, encouraging you to bounce backwards and forwards amongst artists and centuries. Gentileschi’s three-quarter self-portraits discover an echo in a later portray by Elisabetta Sirani of the Egyptian queen Berenice. Gentileschi’s decapitation scene hangs close to a barely earlier portray of the identical topic by the Northern Italian Fede Galizia: stiller, extra exacting, however no shier about equating artwork and violence. The artist signed her title on the steel of Judith’s blade.

Gentileschi, Sirani and Galizia had been all of the daughters of painters. Indeed nearly each feminine artist earlier than the nineteenth century had a father within the occupation. One who didn’t — and my No. 1 draft choose for canon membership, if we’re taking part in that sport — was Sofonisba Anguissola, a minor Lombard noblewoman who obtained an artwork schooling earlier than turning into a lady-in-waiting on the Spanish court docket. She was a fiend at self-portraits, which the artist and her household distributed to hoped-for patrons, and which made her among the many most well-known artists of the late sixteenth century.

This present has three of them, together with a shocking miniature, lent by the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston, wherein the younger Sofonisba gazes sternly whereas holding an enormous medal in entrance of her chest. Her gaze is certainly one of each youthful confidence and utter command, with the humanistic mastery of a real Renaissance lady.

“By Her Hand” does function some drawings, watercolors and woodcuts, although it does little to displace oil portray from its place on the prime of the mountain. (There are not any feminine sculptors right here; they had been rarest of all, although when this present travels to Detroit it’ll introduce a diorama of wax, glass and feathers by the Neapolitan artist Caterina de Julianis.)

A wonderful quartet of pastels by Rosalba Carriera, of 18th-century Venice, has a tough time standing out; slightly generic 18th-century pastels and oils by Marianna Carlevarijs, Veronica Stern Telli and Anna Bacherini Piattoli get misplaced completely. It’s completely effective that some artwork right here seems nice and a few seems workaday. The mixture of high quality enlarges our view of Italian artwork, and with the proof lastly earlier than us we are able to make our personal judgments. But past this preliminary encounter lies the bigger process that Nochlin and Pollock and so many different feminist artwork historians taught us many years in the past, to rethink inventive worth as one thing much less canonical, and fewer depending on the self-esteem of artist as particular person genius.

I’ve anxious so much these days that our rising consideration to gender, race, sexuality and different types of distinction is pushing museums to privilege modern artwork above all — just because, after 1900, it’s a lot simpler to search out (named) artists who aren’t straight white males. But “By Her Hand” at the very least factors to how encyclopedic museums can communicate critically within the current with out ignoring the previous. An analogous impulse animated the Brooklyn Museum’s latest present on gender fluidity in ancient Egyptian art; the Rijksmuseum’s blockbuster on slavery in the Dutch Golden Age; or the landmark present at Columbia University and the Musée d’Orsay on Black models in 19th-century French art. Those exhibits and this one all have their place in a extra fluid and networked artwork historical past, the place the that means of “greatness” continues to be up for grabs.


By Her Hand: Artemisia Gentileschi & Women Artists in Italy, 1500—1800
Through Jan. 9. Wadsworth Atheneum, 600 Main St., Hartford, Conn., (860) 278-2670; thewadsworth.org.

Spread the love

Leave a Comment

twenty six − 25 =